Tube Amps vs Solid State: Which Still Rules the Stage? A debate that keeps the guitar world lit. This post dives into why the choice matters to tone, feel, and stage presence. I want real stories, measured takes, recordings vs stage experience, and tradeoffs between practicality and myth. Drop links to clips, amps, and pedalchains. No marketing fluff: personal tone wins. Tell us how your fingers, not your gear, cha

    I recorded a track on a tube amp, then switched to a modeled solid-state. The difference was clear on headphones, but in a live mix, 90% of the audience wouldn’t notice.

    Stratocaster vs Les Paul — two iconic guitars with distinct tones. Compare pickup configurations, neck profiles, and sustain characteristics to see which fits your style best, and how players adapt each to genres.

    Strat vs Les Paul? Depends on the gig. I want bite for funk—Strat. Crushing rock riffs, Les Paul all the way.

    I’ve been wrestling with this for years. Sometimes I feel like my fingers are part of the pedalboard with analog effects, like the signal flows through me. But digital boards are so convenient, I can dial in anything without carrying a truckload of gear. Does anyone else get that sense of connection or do you find the sound and versatility of digital wins every time?

    Switched to a fully analog pedalboard for a month. My phrasing changed. I swear the pedals made me play more dynamically

    profile picture

    Immortal

    20d ago

    There’s something about holding an old guitar that feels like touching history, but modern builds have consistency that can’t be beat. I’ve played gigs where a vintage neck just sang, and others where I was terrified of a string popping mid-song. How do you reconcile the romance of old instruments with practical realities?

    Modern guitars win for consistency. You can grab two off the rack and they’ll feel nearly identical. Vintage? Every one has a different soul.

    I keep telling myself I’ll build a neat, organized board. Instead, I’ve got cables everywhere, pedals half-velcroed, and settings that I’ll never remember. But every time I stomp around, something magical happens. Anyone else secretly love the chaos?

    Pedalboard Tetris is a game I always lose. But somehow, the more chaotic it looks, the better it sounds.